Legislative Council, Tuesday 17 November 2026
Ms FORREST (Murchison) – Mr President, I rise to make a brief contribution. I did want to listen to what the Leader had to say on behalf of the government. I thank the honourable member for Pembroke for bringing this motion to the House for consideration.
Twice a year, CommSec ranks states and territories on eight indicators. It’s not the final word on any economy, but it is useful. It’s an independent and consistent snapshot. It measures each jurisdiction against its own 10-year average. That’s why the fall is significant. So, it’s a fair test of whether we are doing better or worse than our normal as well as in comparison to other jurisdictions.
The headline for Tasmania is mixed. On economic performance, we slip from fifth to sixth of eight. We’re ranked last on three of the eight indicators. On annual economic momentum we will last. As the report notes, Tasmania recorded the slowest growth. The weakest performance on annual economic activity in the quarter is Tasmania down 0.2 per cent, followed by Western Australia up 0.8 per cent and Queensland up 1.7 per cent. That’s what the report noted. If seasonally adjusted state final demand is used in real terms, comparing the latest result with long run averages, revealed some slight changes in the rankings with Western Australia performing better due to solid export growth, which is no surprise to anyone, I’m sure.
For Tasmania there is a glimmer of good news, or there was when this assessment was done. Tasmania ranked first on unemployment. Our trend jobless rate of 4 per cent is about a quarter below our decade average or it was when this report was done. Annual employment growth of 2.5 per cent is well above the national rate of 1.5 per cent and second only to South Australia.
This was before many of the staffing costs across the state service that would have not yet had full impact as well as many of those very disappointing and regrettable job losses in recent business closures. Hopefully, many of those workers will be able to find alternative employment in a relatively low level of unemployment but remain to be seen how that flows through in following reports.
Housing finance is fourth. Lending grew by 19.4 per cent over the year, which is interesting. It’s more than double the national rate and second only to Northern Territory, however, dwelling starts are only at 0.2 per cent. Hobart’s inflation at 1.7 per cent was below the national rate of 2.1 per cent. The report also contains clear warnings that we should not ignore.
As I mentioned, Tasmania recorded the weakest annual economic growth of any jurisdiction. New vehicle sales fell by more than 9 per cent, the steepest drop in the country. Both are signs of households under pressure. It takes a while for some of those things to flow through. Wage growth of 3.1 per cent was the lowest of any state. So, real wages are rising, but slowly. Investment is softening. Equipment investment fell 3 per cent to over the year and construction work fell 3.6 per cent against a flat result nationally.
Housing supplies of particular concern, dwelling starts at more than 22 per cent below their decade average. I will just say that again, dwelling starts were more than 22 per cent below their decade average. In the last latest quarter, they fell 5.4 per cent, the largest quarterly fall in the country. I thought we were out there busy building homes for Tasmanians. Over the year starts rose just 0.2 per cent as I mentioned earlier, compared to 10.1 per cent nationally. That’s why many people aren’t coming here, they’ve got nowhere to live.
Strong growth in lending has not yet turned into homes being built. Population growth at just 0.2 per cent a year is the lowest in the country. That is barely above the 10-year low record at the end of 2023 and a fraction of the national rate at 1.6 per cent. Consec attributes our position to – I love this term – anaemic private sector demand. It also notes that our momentum is being held back by slowing public investment and the move toward budget repair.
When we’re spending public money, the private sector doesn’t need to get involved as much, but now we’re not, so the private sector needs to have space to come in. We’re not seeing that particularly, perhaps FIRMUS being the only example, but they’re in a bit of pain at the minute too. The last point needs to be considered as a point as part of our role here and ensuring budget repair does not lead to economic harms and further damage the state.
I appreciate this is a difficult balancing act that Treasury has provided advice and guidance on in the Fiscal Sustainability Report, the member for Pembroke mentioned. Much of the advice has not been taken by government in a holistic approach to this problem. For years, public spending has done a lot of work in supporting activity in the state. As the government rightly turns to repairing the budget, the private sector has to stump up or step up and, on these numbers. It is yet to do so.
That is the central challenge. Budget repairs necessary in the fiscal sustainability bidder report makes that clear, but it has to happen alongside conditions that let private investment, housing construction and exports recover. Otherwise, we risk a period where both public and private demand are soft at the same time, which is not a good position to be in. The report itself says Tasmania is waiting for a housing recovery and an export rebound, describes the outlook for private demand as modest. A low population growth needs particular-
Sitting suspended from 4.00 p.m. to 4.30 p.m.
Resumed from above
Ms FORREST (Murchison) – Thank you Mr President, I’d almost completed it, and then I pointed it out to you in the break that I was actually looking at a previous CommSec report, but some of the reporting on it was from the most recent one that the member for Pembroke was referring to. So, if any of those figures are inaccurate, perhaps people go back and look at the 2025 report. That said, the reality is that we’re still at the bottom of the table, and that’s a concern, and that’s referring to the matters that have been raised by Treasury in the Fiscal Sustainability Report, and the need to take those seriously.
Also, our population growth needs particular attention. It does affect our workforce, housing pipeline, share of national revenue and the viability of services in regional communities. A strong labour market, alongside very slow population growth, may also point to tightening workforce constraints ahead.
Rankings move from one report to the next, but from this one to that one, the one the member for Pembroke referred to, we are at the bottom. You can’t actually, on overall ranking, but one addition shouldn’t be read on its own without taking into context the trends and what happens before and after. The direction of travel does matter, though, in that trend, and so does honest acknowledgement of where we sit. We should take heart from our situation, but that is under pressure, and we need to be clear-eyed about the rest.
In the 2026 report, there’s some reporting on it from CommSec. I know that the Hansard can’t record tables, but there is a pretty interesting graphic there that shows that between quarter 2 2025 to quarter 2 2026, Tasmania is at the bottom of the rankings, falling behind New South Wales, Victoria and the Northern Territory, who they were ahead of, at that point. This is unlikely to pick up the cost of cost-cutting across the State Service, and we will need to remain very focused on the broader economy to ensure all Tasmanians have access to services, housing, employment and opportunities that is equitable.
Future reports do need to be considered in that light. We need to take this state of our economy seriously, and as we undertake our role here, ensure that we hold the government to account for decisions that may further harm the state’s economic performance. I note the report.
