CONVERSION PRACTICES PROHIBITION BILL 2026

•

Legislation, Parliament

CONVERSION PRACTICES PROHIBITION BILL 2026

Legislative Council, Tuesday 17 November 2026

Ms FORREST (Murchison) – Mr President, I’m pleased to speak on the Conversion Practices Prohibition Bill 2026. I acknowledge the survivors, advocates, faith leaders, clinicians and legal bodies who have contributed to the development of the bill, many at length and many at personal cost. I also acknowledge the many emails I’ve received expressing concern about this bill, particularly concerns related to religious practice. I respect the right of every Tasmanian to practise their faith, and I note that most of those who wrote with concerns also spoke strongly against harmful conversion practices. On that, we agree.

The challenge, as with all forms of coercive behaviour, is that it can be subtle, occur over long periods of time and seem innocuous at the outset, even loving and caring in the early stages. I agree that the great majority of people who practise their faith do not engage in coercion or in attempts to change another person away from what they see as a preference or practice that does not align with their values and religion.

This bill will not prevent anyone practising their faith. Its purpose is to ensure people do not impose their religious or other beliefs about gender identity or sexual orientation on others in a way that seeks to change or suppress who they are. These practices have no positive effect; they cause harm. This is not a debate about whether conversion practices cause harm. That question has been answered by many, but also by the Tasmanian Law Reform Institute and by every reputable medical and psychological body in this country, and by Tasmanian survivors again and again.

The question for this House and for each of us personally, is whether this bill provides a sound legal instrument for preventing that harm and whether it draws its lines clearly enough that ordinary Tasmanians can know where they stand. Having worked through this bill as it now stands, the submissions and the correspondence, my answer is yes, with a number of questions for the member for Hobart in her reply in the Committee stage. I do acknowledge the lengthy and extensive second reading contribution that does cover off a lot of these matters, but there may be some things that the member wishes to reiterate in her response or reply to the debate.

I also want to put on the record the concerns raised with me by those who oppose the bill and seek further information from the member for Hobart in response to some of those concerns. Those who took the time to write to me deserve to see their concerns considered, and I think it’s important that we do, regardless of our position on the bill.

So, why are we here? The Tasmanian Law Reform Institute’s Final Report No. 32 released in April 2022 found that conversion practices were occurring in Tasmania. It seems to me, after listening to many Tasmanians, that this is still occurring – not just in 2022; it’s been occurring since. The TLRI catalogued the harms: isolation from family and faith communities, loss of trust in religious leaders and health professionals, self‑hatred, anxiety, depression, trauma, substance misuse, reluctance to seek medical care, and suicidal ideations, attempts, and deaths. Those harms may last for years – for some, obviously for life.

This is not new to Tasmania and in the 1970s, men convicted of homosexuality were subject to drug‑based diversion therapy at the Royal Derwent Hospital. In the 1990s, public conferences promoting conversion were held in Tasmania. In 2021, research by La Trobe University and the University of Tasmania found that around one in 20 LGBTQIA+ Tasmanians have been through conversion practices and that survivors were three to four times more likely than other LGBTQIA+ people to have post‑traumatic stress disorder and to attempt suicide.

New national research from La Trobe University through the Writing Themselves In and Private Lives surveys asked LGBTQIA+ Australians whether anyone had tried or discussed trying to change or suppress their sexuality or gender. Almost half of the young LGBTQIA+ people had said this had happened in their lifetime and more than one quarter in the past 12 months. More than two in five adults said it had happened in their lifetime, and one in 10 in the past year. I know that this measures exposure – it is not the same thing as having gone through conversion practices – but it shows how many people are still being told that who they are needs to change.

The government committed to act. Its consultation draft released in December 2023 was criticised from several directions and did not progress. But then New South Wales and South Australia have legislated, joining Victoria, Queensland, and the ACT.

The community’s response has been substantial on both sides. More than 600 Tasmanians had written in support of the bill through Equality Tasmania, and nearly 6000 signed the House of Assembly petition. I am sure every other member in this House has also received emails from Tasmanians who are opposed and have concerns, and I will come to those points as well. It is a little bit difficult when people write emails and don’t acknowledge where they’re from. They may well not be even in Tasmania, so I don’t tend to reply to those. I reply to those that are from Tasmania.

I also acknowledge that for many young Tasmanians growing up, it is normal to question their own sexual desires, sexual orientation, and gender identity, just as we question many aspects of our life in the world at that time. I hope most members can remember being in adolescence – it’s a pretty challenging time in lots of ways. But this questioning about who you are, what life means, all those really big, important questions that are enormous as an adolescent is normal, healthy, and not in need of prevention, suppression, or discouragement.

I also acknowledge there are a number of people who have contacted me with concerns regarding experiences, either personal or of a loved one, who has had really significant challenges with feeling safe, affirmed, and comfortable living with the sex they were assigned at birth. Some have sought to retransition after determining that their birth sex was right for them after all. It is a time of often great uncertainty for these people, and they need to be supported, not told they’re broken and need to be fixed. These are enormously difficult decisions and times for individuals, and what is needed most during these processes and decision-making is support, acceptance and understanding, to try and avoid any shame and adverse mental and/or physical health outcomes. Any form of coercion during these times is wrong.

Shame is a terrible thing. Shame is what drives so many people to the edge of despair, and shame is exactly what these people, who are being told they’re not right, in the body, or the way they are, is exactly the intention of those comments: to create shame.

It is right that we listen to what survivors have told us. I know we’ve received many emails describing experiences and the trauma that followed from too many Australians and Tasmanians. I just want to relay a small number, and I know the member for Hobart referred to a couple. I will use the names of these people who have been public about their story.

Bronwyn was born and raised in Tasmania. At 16, after her mother saw a tender moment between Bronwyn and a girl from her class at a birthday party, she was taken to a hypnotherapist in Hobart. She cannot tell you what was said in those sessions. She remembers climbing the metal stairs to the rooms, waking in the chair, and feeling sick and drained. Her Year 9 school reports record that she was absent too often to be assessed. A fog settled over her that did not lift until she was 30. At 30, when she fell in love with a woman, her church removed her from teaching Sunday school, and said that she might harm children, and offered her conversion therapy again. She refused. She’s now 48, and still in therapy for what was done to her at the age of 16.

Glenn is Christian and gay. For more than 20 years he followed conversion programs, many of them here in Tasmania. He describes nine hours in prayer ministry, including an exorcism in a house in South Hobart, five more hours at a church in St Leonards, and a session at a camp in Ulverstone. All in the hope of being healed of his attraction. He saw a Christian councillor at Kingston Beach who used prayer and talk therapy to address what she called ‘the underlying issues.’ Congregations helped pay for him to attend programs interstate. At 50, after a lifetime of celibacy, Glenn admitted to himself that nothing had changed. He described the loneliness and despair as having nearly killed him.

Glenn has written to members about how prayer can be used as a conversion practice and I want to relay some of his words, and I thank him for being so brave, and for being here, as well as for writing his words to us. He said:

I am writing as a survivor of conversion practice in Tasmania. I understand some MPs have expressed concern that prayer may come within the scope of the Conversion Practices Prohibition Bill 2026. Some may wish to remove prayer altogether. In response, I want to give you a personal insight into the issue of conversion practices and prayer.

During my 21 years of suppressing my sexuality through conversion practices, I found prayer practices to be the most harrowing and damaging of all conversion practices. I was repeatedly advised to pray to God to heal me. I cried rivers pleading with Him. Prayer was also an integral part of the exorcism I was subject to. I had people praying over me, sometimes for hours on end. These practices were intimidating and frightening. I felt very vulnerable, and there is a deep power imbalance, but there is an even deeper level of risk. Prayer is the closest a Christian can come to the divine; it is a personal communication with God.

He went on:

But when prayer fails, there is nowhere left to go. When it failed for me, I felt like I would always be unworthy of God, and that he had abandoned me. For too many people undertaking conversion practices, this is the point at which they are most vulnerable, where suicide is seen as the only option. Fortunately, I did not go down that path. After prayer failed, I chose to accept who I am, but I know others are not so lucky.

I thank Glenn for being willing to talk about how prayer was used in this circumstance, and also to reference that power imbalance. I know that matter was raised by a Uniting Church pastor in our briefing today. Any position of power can be used in such a way.

To be very clear about prayer, which I accept is an important part of Christian life, only prayer which is intended as a conversion practice should be prohibited by the Conversion Practices Prohibition Bill, and the bill already makes this clear. Glen implores us: please do not exempt prayer from the bill entirely. He said:

Prayer based conversion practices is where the greatest damage is done and where the law must focus if it is to be effective. It needs to be a boundary in place that allows a person to feel free to be who they are.

This is what suppression can look like when it’s carried out through prayer and pressure to change or conform. None of what Glenn referred to took place in a formal clinic.

Anthony, a former Pentecostal preacher who entered a church residential program in 1972, also has an important story. He involuntarily, he says, ‘voluntarily needs to be taken in and considered in context’. He said that when you have been taught that part of you is sinful and broken, seeking to change it feels like the only option. He has since supported more than 4000 survivors. One of them told him that of 40 friends he made in conversion therapy, only six are still alive.

Nathan Despot, the co-founder of Brave Network and SOGICE Survivors, that sexual orientation and gender identity change efforts makes an important point. He said that practises that do the most damage are rarely formal programs. They are carried through prayer groups, mentoring, counselling and referrals in softer language, healing, purity, celibacy, exploring causes. A law that only captures overt programs will miss most of what is actually happening.

And from my own electorate, Father Greg Rowlands, an Anglican priest in Burnie for 38 years, wrote of a vulnerable man who, in a mental health crisis, confided in the cleric that he was gay. He was offered contact with people who would help him suppress his orientation. Father Rowlands calls conversion practice is not therapy but psychological assault.

As I’ve stated, people of faith have written to me on both sides of this bill in all good conscience. I’ve received detail analysis signed by Leslie, Anglican Diocese of Tasmania, the Australian National Imams Council, the Shia Muslim Council, the Coptic Orthodox Church and the Seventh Day Adventist Church, the Presbyterian Church of Tasmania, the Salvation Army, Tasmanian Baptist, Christian schools and others. They support laws against coercive and genuinely harmful practices, and they raise specific concerns about where the bill draws its lines. I take those concerns seriously and will address them. As I said, I’ll ask the member for Hobart to address some of these.

We have also heard from the Uniting Church Synod of Victoria and Tasmania, whose National Assembly resolved in 2022 that sexual orientation and gender identity change efforts are harmful, and that prayer and pastoral care should never be used to harm or condemn anyone. Closer to home, the Reverend Dr Cornelia Hoffman, who’s with us here today, minister of the Cradle Coast cluster of Uniting Church congregations from Devonport to Wynyard and herself a Doctor of Law, has studied the bill as well. She describes it as fair and pragmatic, built on the Law Reform Institute’s educational and preventative approach. She sent 37 letters of support from members of her congregation, many of them my constituents.

I’ve also heard from people of faith in my electorate who remain deeply concerned about aspects of the bill and I’ve also heard from the Anglican priest in Burnie who supports the bill while his own diocese has concerns about it. There are very mixed views amongst the religious people. The important distinction between genuine pastoral care and a practice directed at changing or suppressing who someone is needs to be clear to all. Bishop Richard Condi of the Anglican Diocese of Tasmania has raised a specific concern. I know the member for Hobart did refer to this in part. The diocese code of conduct for church workers requires faithfulness in marriage and chastity in singleness. Regardless of their sexual orientation, he informed me that he does have gay members of the clergy, but the code of conduct requires faithfulness in marriage and chastity and singleness.

The bill amends the Anti-Discrimination Act definition for sexual orientation to include intimate and sexual relationship with, and the bill adopts that definition so the diocese and Bishop Condi fears that, combined with the prohibition on suppression, its code could become unlawful. I’ve discussed with the Bishop Condie, and I know others have as well. Looking at the bill in its entirety, it does remain unclear to me, and there are sections of the member for Hobart’s second reading speech that didn’t actually clarify it particularly for me.

So, I ask the member for Hobart to be very clear about this in the contribution, and there will no doubt be further discussion, probably in the Committee stage, on this as well.

I also spoke directly with the Anti‑Discrimination Commissioner about this definition because it is amending the act under which the Anti‑Discrimination Commissioner operates, who was clear to me that the need to ensure the language in the bill, including amendments to the Anti-Discrimination Act, are contemporary and reflect contemporary understandings. I’ve pulled in two ways here, so it is a bit of a challenge.

I do appreciate the concerns of Bishop Condie, and I believe, when read in context, it does remain unclear if he will be able to fully apply the code of conduct to members of his clergy as he requires. As I read the bill:

A conversion practice must be directed toward a person on the basis of their actual or perceived sexual orientation for the purpose of changing, suppressing or eradicating it. [tbc]

Bishop Condie’s concern is that in enforcing the code of conduct for clergy, asking them not to act on a desire for a sexual relationship outside of marriage, or to remain celibate if they’re not married, the Church could fall foul of this provision. It is the intimate or sexual relationship that is the issue for the church, not the sexual orientation itself – going back to the code of conduct requiring faithfulness in marriage and celibacy in singleness.

I know that clause 5(4)(e) expressly provides that the making application or communication of general requirements for membership or leadership of a religious community is not of itself a conversion practice, and I initially thought that may be the adequate cover. There’s still a question that remains, and I would ask the member for Hobart to address it. A code applied equally to all clergy could be read as exactly that.

Clause 5(4)(b) also now protects the expression of relief and discernment of religious education, pastoral care or prayer. What the bill could appear to do is prevent the use of the code or anything else as a tool to target an individual in order to change or suppress acting on that sexual desire in a way that is contrary to the code of conduct. If a member of the clergy is asked to suppress the desire for an extramarital relationship or an unmarried member of the clergy is expected to remain celibate and suppress the desire to engage in an intimate or sexual relationship as the code requires, I can see how this could possibly be problematic. This is the distinction that requires a clear response.

Equality Tasmania’s view is that the phrase is included only as an indicator of sexual orientation, not to change the purpose of the bill, and that removing it could be seen as desexualising same‑sex relationships. That was a similar concern that the Anti‑Discrimination Commissioner raised with me when I spoke with her.

I think it’s important that we understand how clause 5(4)(e) applies to a generally applicable code of conduct and to explain how the amended definition of ‘sexual orientation’ interacts with the definition of a ‘conversion practice’. I appreciate a similar provision exists in Victoria’s Equal Opportunity Act in terms of their definition, and a similar definition has been included more recently in the Northern Territory’s relevant legislation. That was a point the Anti‑Discrimination Commissioner was making too, that while we’re reviewing these acts we should try to look for the most contemporary definition. So, I see where it’s come from and ask the member for Hobart to respond to that.

Members of religious groups have raised clause 5(4) and in particular the words ‘of itself’ as ill defined and potentially problematic. A number of religious leaders wrote to me regarding this matter, and I’ll refer to one, as I think it reflects the sincerity of many who wrote. One pastor wrote:

Christians have a good reason to take great care with their words. We follow a God who speaks in love, who cares about how people are trusted when they are vulnerable. That is why the bill matters to us and why I want the law to be clear for the people it affects, including people like me, who may be asked for help.

In some conversations, people come to me genuinely wanting to talk, pray or think through their struggles with gender and sexuality. I want to care for them well and I want to know whether where the law stands when I do. [tbc]

A number raised concern regarding, as I said, the words ‘of itself’. I did respond to some; I haven’t managed to get to all the emails. I don’t know if anyone else has, either, but there have been a few too many to respond to all of them, but I did respond to some on this particular point. As I read ‘of itself’ means the activity on its own is never a convergent practice. It’s not a blanket exemption. It’s not intended to be a blanket exemption. It’s referring to that particular matter just of itself is not a conversion practice. However, if the same activity was used as part of conduct aimed at changing or suppressing or eradicating a particular person’s orientation or sexual identity, the protection would not cover it, and neither should it.

Clause 5 deals with legitimate activity in two ways. Clause 5(3) says a conversion practice does not include good-faith healthcare or genuinely supporting a person’s coping development or identity exploration. This is not a carve-out conduct that means it is outside the act entirely.

Clause 5(4) says –

for the avoidance of doubt, the listed conduct does not of itself constitute a conversion practice.

I read this as a clarification, making it clear rather not an exemption, and the member for Hobart’s been clear about that. For the avoidance of doubt, suggests that activities listed in clause 5(4) would never be caught by definition in the first place. That is because, done in the ordinary way, they lack the elements in clause 5(1), which states a conversion practice must be directed towards a particular person done on the basis of that person’s sexual orientation or gender identity, and done for the purpose of changing, suppressing or eradicating or inducing the person to do so.

A sermon, a statement of church teaching, or a code of conduct applied towards clergy in general, to me seems it’s not directed at an individual because of their orientation or for the purpose of changing them. So, I do believe that clause 5(4) says so expressly as a reassurance. ‘Of itself’ ensures the door to misuse is not left open. The listed activity cannot be used as a shield if it forms part of conduct that does that does not meet those three elements.

I went back and looked at the consultation draft and read some of the information that informed some amendments made before it even landed in the House of Assembly, and the consultation draft used the words ‘provided the conduct is not engaged in as part of a conversion practice’, and this was criticised in that consultation as circular. Therefore, the words ‘of itself’ were used to replace it, to make it simple and clean.

Some suggested we should delete clause 5(4) altogether. In my view, deleting clause 5(4) would remove the very reassurance many faith leaders have asked for. The list is long, longer than any other state, largely because of concerns raised during the consultation. Removing ‘of itself’ would turn each item into an absolute exemption, which to me is just absolutely not on.

Conversion practices often borrow the form of legitimate activity – prayer, pastoral care, counselling – to actually gain legitimacy. An absolute exemption from prayer would make Glenn’s nine hours of prayer ministry and exorcism lawful simply because it was delivered as prayer. Equality Tasmania has told members that they would find it hard to support the bill without those words. ‘Of itself’ is the balance point between those two outcomes.

To the person who wrote to me, and like many of them, if someone comes to you wanting to talk, pray or think through their struggles and you care for them without steering them towards a predetermined outcome of changing or suppressing who they are, that is not a conversion practice. I do note if there were concerns when enacted, courts could look at the second reading speech and the committee debate when a provision may be seen as ambiguous. I don’t believe it is overly ambiguous, but if that was the case, and we know that the Acts Interpretation Act 1931 makes that provision.

Secondly, clause 2(5) allows the commissioner to issue practice guidelines and require consultation with people representing those who guidelines will affect. I know there will be a lot more work to do on this, and I encourage the commissioner to develop guidelines with worked examples to help people understand what it might look like in consultation with faith communities as well as members of the LGBTQIA+ community and ideally before the act commences. I know there is a delay to the commencements, which should allow that work to happen.

A question I have for the government, and I don’t know who can respond on behalf of the government, but hopefully someone can, many of whom have supported this bill: will the Office of the Anti-Discrimination Commission and the commissioner be provided with the necessary funding and resources to undertake this critical educative role? I don’t know who can respond to that because it’s not really a matter for the member for Hobart who’s in charge of this bill, but I will come back to that.

I asked the member for Hobart to confirm that ‘of itself’ means illicit activity can only form part of the conversion practice where it is directed at a particular person on the basis of their sexual orientation or gender identity for the purposes of changing or suppressing it.

I also wish to briefly outline what I understand the bill actually does, for context to my decision to support the bill. As I understand it – and I’m sure the member for Hobart will correct me if I’m wrong at any point – the bill defines a conversion practice as conduct directed towards a person on the basis of their sexual orientation or gender identity for the purpose of changing, suppressing or eradicating it or inducing them to do so. It excludes good-faith healthcare by any registered health practitioner that complies with legal, professional, ethical requirements and conduct that genuinely supports a person’s coping, development or identity exploration.

It provides for the avoidance of doubt that the following do not of themselves constitute a conversion practice: public debate, expressing a belief or principle, including a religious belief or principle, in a sermon, religious education, pastoral care, or prayer, including that a religious teaching ought to be followed or applied and/or an expression that a belief or principle ought to be followed or applied. It states that relevant religious teachings are, or what a religion says about a specific topic, applies general religious membership or leadership requirements such as abiding with codes of conduct for clergy.[tbc 6.12.30]

The bill includes, now, as amended downstairs, as the member for Hobart alluded to, guardians discussing or providing guidance, support or advice to their children on sexual orientation, gender identity, sexual activity or religion. I know there were a number of emails where parents raised concerns around that.

It also applies to approved relationships and sexuality education, the avoidance of doubt, health practitioners providing in-good-faith health information about treatment and non-treatment options, including their potential benefits, risks, limitations, and uncertainties, helping a person explore their identity without directing or predetermining or seeking to influence the person toward a particular outcome, and discussing with a person the person’s desire or intention to detransition, desist, reverse, continue, or modify a social or medical transition.

The bill also creates an Education, Prevention and Response Scheme administered by the Conversion Practices Commissioner built around education, voluntary facilitation and referral. The bill reserves investigation and coercive pastoral matters that meet all four tests in clause 39, a serious issue, a possible material contravention, an effect on a class or group of people, and advancing the act’s objectives. It provides a tribunal pathway for compensation and for a respondent to clear their name, and it creates criminal offences only for conduct that is intentional and causes injury and is negligent as to that injury, with the Director of Public Prosecution’s written consent required before any prosecution.

The structure and framework for this bill is prevention first. The criminal law is the backstop. It’s not the front door, as it would seem some people fear. The bill is materially better than the draft released in July, and better again after its passage through the other place. Many of the changes respond directly to the Law Reform Institute and to those who actually oppose the bill, but also those who wish to make it better.

I acknowledge the willingness of the bill’s proponents to be willing to accept those amendments and work collaboratively to do so. After public consultation, the child-specific offence that required no proof of injury was removed. The offence now requires both injury and negligence [6.15.03] Victoria. The health exemption now uses the institute’s preferred good faith test and covers every registered practitioner, including nurses and psychologists and all those in between. As someone who trained as a nurse and midwife, I will say this, good clinical practice starts with the person in front of you. Not a conclusion reached before they walk in the door.

The bill prescribes no clinical pathway. What it rules out is care that begins from the premise that a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity is a defect that needs to be explained away. In the House of Assembly, further amendments were made, including the parental protection now covers guardians discussing or providing guidance, support, or advice to their children – the wording used in New South Wales and South Australia, and I welcome this change. It was a genuine area of concern.

The religious protection now names sermons, religious education, and pastoral care alongside prayer. Age‑appropriate relationships and sexual education under improved curriculum is expressly protected. I must say, as a former sex educator, this is important. Children really do want to discuss these matters. I’ve been in sessions with young people – primary school kids – who ask the most open and honest questions about all things. All things. What they want is a straight, honest answer. It’s quite enlightening and really beautiful. I do miss that – being in the schools with those kids. What they need and what we need is to be open, honest and non‑judgmental in our approach. Just give them the facts, tell them the truth.

Another amendment that was made – the provision deeming employers can be liable for offences by employers, contractors, and volunteers has been removed. Vicarious liability is now civil only, limited to the course of employment where the reasonable precaution is defence.

The Limitation Act and Civil Liability Act changes are now prospective only and carry a qualifier that an unlawful act at the time is not child abuse. There is no retrospective exposure. I know that was a concern from a number.

Then the inclusion of a review every five years, especially including its effect on freedom of religion, belief and expression, parental rights, children’s rights, and health outcomes. The commencement is up to 12 months after royal assent and the civil liability changes up to 24 months, giving organisations time to prepare, including the Anti‑Discrimination Commissioner.

I do want to be fair to the faith leaders whose analysis I’ve referred to. Their comparison in some of the emails they sent with other states and comments they made – and many of them – particularly early on were based on the bill that was introduced. We do know that there’s been many changes made in the other House and that has perhaps dealt with some of their concerns, though there will still be those who oppose the bill. I accept that, but the more challenging matters have been addressed.

I do just want to go briefly through the concerns raised by church leaders who opposed the bill and give my response to some of those. With regard to parents, it had been claimed that this bill will jail parents who do not immediately affirm a child’s gender identity or sexual orientation. It will not. Guardians discussing, guiding, supporting, advising their children on these matters are expressly protected. To be prosecuted, a person must intentionally engage in a conversion practice that causes harm or injury, be negligent as to that injury, and have all of it proved beyond reasonable doubt, and the DPP must consent. Parental uncertainty, questions, and taking time to understand a child are not conversion practices. Anyone who’s raised kids knows this. They want honest answers to questions. You can express your belief, but you can’t tell them they’re wrong.

With regards to prayer, pastoral care, and applying religious teaching, sermons, and religious education, pastoral care and prayer are protected as expressions of belief. What is not protected is prayer used as a means of trying to change or suppress someone who may be struggling with gender identity or sexual orientation that doesn’t align with the church’s view. As I said, Glenn’s nine hours of prayer, ministry, and exorcism and the circle of elders praying over Bronwyn and her partner at a friend’s funeral are why a wholesale exemption for prayer would exempt much of what the bill exists to prevent.

Faith leaders have asked about two specific situations: praying with someone at their request for strength to live according to their own beliefs and helping someone work out how religious teaching applies in their own circumstances. Neither is, of itself, a conversion practice, as I understand it. Clause 54(b) protects expressions of belief in pastoral care and prayer, and clause 54(c) protects expressing that belief ought to be followed or applied. The question is always purpose. If their purpose is to try and change someone, or suppress their gender identity or sexual orientation, that’s where the problem lies. Not just the fact that you – they can express what they personally believe, but not that a person needs to change, or be healed, or fixed.

With regard to consent, it is said that adults who freely choose these practice should be left alone. I understand that instinct to say that, but there are many accounts of people who went in willingly after years of being told that the alternative, the only alternative, was losing God, their family and community. Social isolation is indeed a great penalty to pay. Whilst they might consent, is it a fully informed consent? Is it really of their own free will, when the options are ostracisation from that community? I would say not. Agreement given under such pressure is not informed consent, and we wouldn’t accept it anywhere else in healthcare, and Victoria takes the same approach.

With regard to questions around celibacy and personal choice, some have asked whether supporting an adult who chooses celibacy for their own faith reasons is now unlawful? It’s not, of itself. The person’s own choice about how they live is theirs to make. What the bill targets is conduct whose purpose is to change, or suppress, a person’s sexual orientation. The decades Glenn spent being told his affection was a wound to be healed, are examples.

A number of those opposed to the bill also raised concerns around the definitions of ‘suppression’, including ‘single acts’ and ‘purpose.’ Critics say: ‘suppression’ or ‘inducing’ are undefined and too broad, that a singular interaction can be a conversion practice and that the bill does not say whether a prohibited practice must be the main purpose of the division, and the definition requires no coercion or harm. The suppression, or inducing, are consistent with other legislation, particularly the references in Victoria, which has operated since 2021. But suppression has a normal dictionary meaning, and once we start trying to define things, you often get yourself tied up in knots. So, suppression is a genuine concern, in its natural use of the word, and practices that do not promise change, but aim to make a person conceal, or deny who they are, cause just as much harm. In my view, the definition focused on purpose, and deliberately so. This is because the same conversation, prayer, or counselling session, can be supportive, or harmful, depending on what it’s for.

A single act can be a conversion practice under Victorian law too. I know it’s different in South Australia. The bill requires the Commission to consider whether conduct was isolated, or part of the pattern, and the nature and extent of that harm. The Commissioner may decline a report that lacks substance where the conduct is not a conversion practice, and may investigate only serious or systemic matters. Harm is an element of every criminal offence.

Some critics of the bill also raised several concerns around reporting mechanisms, the role, powers and functions of the Commissioner. It’s important to note that a Commissioner can decline, as I said, frivolous or vexatious reports, and investigations require all four clause 39 tests. Individual breaches go toward education, as I said, education is the front door facilitation, or to the tribunal. The Commissioner must have regard to natural justice and an allegation alone is never enough for enforcement. The Commissioner must be satisfied a conversion practice occurred before accepting an undertaking, or issuing a compliance notice. A compliance notice can be reviewed by the tribunal.

Some of these provisions are the same as Victoria’s, and some have taken a slightly different approach. I know that some, including the LGB Alliance, and other parents groups, argue that gender identity should be excluded from the bill, raising concern that the bill will entrench a particular model of care for young people. The TLRI dealt with both sexual orientation, and gender identity, because conversion ideology treats them alike, and the harm is similar. Excluding gender identity would leave trans, and gender diverse Tasmanian exposed, and making Tasmania a haven for such practices.

The bill does not prescribe a clinical pathway. It protects good‑faith care that complies with professional requirements, information about treatment and non‑treatment options, identity exploration without a predetermined outcome and discussion of detransition. It does not change clinical guidelines.

There have been a number calling for further inquiry, including the bill to be referred to a committee. I don’t support the need for further committee inquiries. I note the TLRI’s extensive review, the government’s 2023 consultation, two rounds of consultation on this bill and the independent review required after five years and the willingness of proponents to take on feedback and amend the bill in the ways it has been.

As I mentioned earlier, I’m conscious that legislation of this kind is only as effective as its resourcing. The bill rests on education and prevention, and the commissioner’s role is given to the Anti‑Discrimination Commissioner. I ask whether cost has been estimated and whether the government intends to fund it, noting that we have other inadequately funded commissioners in this state. The cost of not acting is also real: survivors’ lifelong mental health needs, lost productivity and lost lives.

To close, I just want to share the words of a community leader who captured my views on this matter, just in part. She wrote:

Growing up has never been easy, but today’s young people often find themselves caught between competing messages. On one hand, there is a growing understanding and acceptance of diversity in all its forms. On the other hand, there remain attitudes and beliefs rooted in earlier generations that can leave young people feeling judged and misunderstood or pressure to conform to expectations that do not reflect who they are.

As a mother, I believe every child deserves to know they are loved and accepted unconditionally. Young people should be encouraged to develop confidence in themselves, not taught that an intrinsic part of their identity is something to be hidden, shamed, suppressed or changed. The adolescent years are often marked by uncertainty, loneliness and vulnerability. As a parent, my heart ached, witnessing my own child’s distress, but I often found myself thinking about the even greater burden carried by those who are made to feel ashamed of who they are.

Researcher and author Brene Brown described shame as ‘the intensely painful belief that we are fundamentally flawed and therefore unworthy of love, belonging, and connection.’ For a young person still developing their sense of self, that burden can be devastating. Instead of seeing themselves as facing a challenge or difference, they come to believe that they themselves are bad. No child should carry the weight of feeling unworthy of love, acceptance, or belonging simply because of who they are.

Our responsibility as parents, leaders and communities is to replace shame with understanding, fear with compassion and rejection with genuine support. Conversion practice can undermine that sense of self-worth by sending a message that a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity is somehow flawed and in need of correction. Such practices cause lasting emotional and psychological harm at a time when young people need affirmation, guidance and care. The impacts of shame and rejection can extend well beyond adolescence, affecting relationships, self-esteem, and a person’s ability to live authentically throughout their life, including as parents, partners and members of future generations.

She closed off with:

Supporting this legislation is, in my view, an expression of those values. It reflects a commitment to ensuring that every Tasmanian, regardless of their sexual orientation or gender identity, can live free from practices that seek to change or deny who they are. It sent a message that every person is worthy of respect and acceptance and there is a place for them in our communities exactly as they are.

I couldn’t have put it better. The bill does not ask anyone to give up sincerely held beliefs. It asks us to protect the dignity, safety and wellbeing of every Tasmanian, particularly the young and the vulnerable.

Every member of this place has received correspondence on this bill from people of goodwill. I have heard from survivors carrying damage decades later, from a priest and a minister from the north‑west coast, from 37 members of a north‑west congregation, from a mayor writing as a mother and from faith leaders who share the goal of protecting people from harm but worry about where the line falls. I acknowledge them all.

I know that people who are gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, non‑binary, queer and asexual are not ill or damaged or sinful or broken; but they can be harmed, broken, made ill and damaged by conversion practices. The people this bill seeks to protect are our family members and our friends. They are loved members of our families and community. They are mothers, fathers, sisters, brothers, sons, daughters and other relatives and friends. They are us. They must be able to live their lives safe from conversion and harm that would seek to correct or heal an ailment they do not have. Being gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, non-binary, gender diverse, queer or asexual is not abnormal and is not in need of treatment. Members of the LGBTIQA+ community must be safe and free to live their lives free from coercion or conversion practices, just as heterosexual and cisgender people are.

I know the harm conversion practices do. I think back to the 16-year-old girl climbing the metal stairs to the hypnotherapist rooms in Hobart; to a man driving from Launceston to South Hobart, St Leonards and Ulverstone year after year, hoping to be healed of something that was never an illness. I know we need to act. Sadly, this bill cannot undo what was done to them. I’m sorry that it happened to them. I hope you feel some benefit from seeing this practice recognised as wrong and truly harmful, and from knowing that you have been seen and heard.

What this bill can do is to make it far less likely that another Tasmanian goes through the same. It does so through prevention education first and criminal law only for intentional injurious conduct and real protections are there for religious expression, parental guidance, and proper healthcare. Tasmania was the last state to decriminalise homosexuality. We do not need to be the last to protect LGBTIQA+ Tasmanians from practices that tell them they are broken when they are not.

To all Tasmanians and any Australians or anyone for that matter, who may be questioning their own sexual orientation or gender, I say this, just be yourself. I see you, you are special, I care about you, and you’re absolutely fine just as you are.