Legislative Council, Tuesday 27 October 2026
Ms FORREST (Murchison) – Mr President, I move –
(1) That the Legislative Council notes:
(a) fragrance sensitivity, also referred to as multiple chemical sensitivity in its broader form, is a documented and often debilitating health condition affecting a significant proportion of the Australian and Tasmanian population, characterised by adverse physiological responses to fragranced consumer products including perfumes, colognes, air fresheners, cleaning products, and scented personal care items;
(b) peer-reviewed research published in Air Quality, Atmosphere & Health (Steinemann, 2019), drawing on nationally representative surveys across four countries including Australia, found that:
(i) approximately one in three adults in Australia (33 per cent), report adverse health effects from fragranced consumer products;
(ii) commonly reported health problems include respiratory difficulties, mucosal symptoms, migraine headaches, skin rashes, and asthma attacks;
(iii) 7.7 per cent of Australians had lost workdays or a job in the past year due to illness from fragranced product exposure in the workplace;
(iv) A single application of perfume can release over 100 different chemical compounds into the air, many of which are not listed on product labels due to trade secret protections;
(v) fragrance-free policies have been implemented in workplaces, schools, healthcare facilities, public buildings, and other indoor environments around the world, and national surveys indicate that more people prefer fragrance free rather than fragranced environments;
(vi) among the general population, 47.8 per cent would support a fragrance-free policy in the workplace, compared to only 20.4 per cent who would not.
(2) That the Legislative Council acknowledges:
(a) fragrance sensitivity is an invisible condition, and this invisibility contributes to a pattern of scepticism, dismissal, and minimisation that compounds the burden on those living with the condition, creates barriers to disclosure, and discourages people from seeking workplace accommodations or participating fully in public life;
(b) fragrance sensitivity can have a profound impact on people’s professional and personal lives, including their ability to maintain employment, attend events, access public spaces, and perform their work, and many Tasmanians living with this condition do so largely in silence for fear of disbelief or ridicule;
(c) fragrance sensitivity is a legitimate and debilitating health issue deserving of the same seriousness afforded to other airborne health triggers, including cigarette smoke and known allergens;
(d) workplaces, government and public institutions should develop and implement fragrance-awareness or fragrance-reduction policies as a reasonable and practical measure to support access and inclusion;
(e) the culture surrounding invisible illness needs to change, and institutions have a role to play in modelling respectful, evidence‑informed responses to accommodation requests; and
(f) those who raise health and accessibility concerns in institutional settings are entitled to have those concerns treated with confidentiality, dignity, and professionalism.
(3) That the Legislative Council calls on the government to:
(a) consider what steps can be taken within government services and public institutions to reduce fragrance exposure and support those with fragrance related health conditions;
(b) consider whether public health guidance on fragrance sensitivity could be developed or promoted to assist employers, event organisers, schools, and health care facilities; and
(c) reflect on the importance of maintaining confidentiality and trust when individuals raise health and accessibility concerns in professional or institutional contexts.
The motion considers three matters. First, to note the evidence on fragrance sensitivity; second, to acknowledge that people who live with it are too often disbelieved; and third, to call on the government to consider practical, low‑cost steps within its own services and institutions to respond.
It does not ask anyone to stop wearing perfume or aftershave or other strong fragrances when out and about in public places or in their own home. It does not propose a ban. It asks us to take seriously conditions that a substantial body of research says and, since I raised this matter publicly ‑ well, I didn’t intend to raise it publicly, it was raised publicly for me ‑ I’ve heard that there are many, many people in our community who have this challenge. The research says it affects around one in three Australian adults to some degree and that for a smaller group it is actually disabling.
Members may have heard from constituents about this issue as I have, and for some I’ve spoken to, this is quite debilitating. What did strike me in some of these conversations and in many emails I received when I raised this matter is not only the physical symptoms – the physical symptoms are very real and quite debilitating – but people often said they had stopped raising it because they expect to be dismissed, or worse, bullied or treated disrespectfully in the workplace by co‑workers and managers. Sounds pretty right to me.
Some make light of this very real issue and dismiss it, especially if they themselves are not impacted. As I said, there is a growing body of work in this area that clearly shows there is a very real issue here. The most comprehensive work in the field has been done here in Australia by Prof. Anne Steinemann, then of the University of Melbourne. In 2019 she published an international study in the peer‑reviewed journal Air Quality, Atmosphere & Health, which drew on nationally representative surveys of around 1100 adults in each of four countries: the United States, Australia, the United Kingdom, and Sweden. Across the four countries, 32.2 per cent of adults reported adverse health effects from fragrance to consumer products. In Australia the figure was 33 per cent. That is one in three. One in three Australians.
The most commonly reported problems are respiratory difficulties, reported by 16.7 per cent of the general population; mucosal symptoms, such as watery eyes and congestion, by 13.2 per cent; migraine/headaches by 12.6 per cent; skin problems by 9.1 per cent; and asthma attacks by 7 per cent. We know that people die from asthma. Seven per cent of that 33 per cent – one in three – can suffer an asthma attack. I’m not suggesting they’re going to die from that particular event, but asthma is a condition where things build on each other. It might be that you’re having a high pollen day and you come into work and someone’s wearing a really overpowering fragrance. Then you’re in a serious health crisis. That doesn’t diminish all the other things that I’ve already listed because they are health‑related problems and serious to the person who’s suffering them.
These products involve not only perfumes; they include air fresheners, cleaning products, laundry products, scented candles, and personal care products. The single most common trigger was simply being near someone wearing a fragrance product – reported by 20.1 per cent of people. For some, the effects go well beyond discomfort. Across the four countries, 9.5 per cent of the general population reported effects severe enough to be considered disabling under each country’s disability legislation, including our own disability discrimination act. The burden is heavier still for people already living with other conditions. Steinemann’s work found that 57.8 per cent of people with asthma, 75.8 per cent of people with autism, and 82 per cent of people with chemical sensitivity reported adverse effects from fragrance products.
To be clear about what the surveys show as well as what they don’t, these are self‑reported; they’re cross‑sectional surveys and much of the work comes from one research group. I want to make note of that – the limitations – because all research has its limitations, I think it’s important to be clear about that, but they do tell us what people experience. They do not, on their own, tell us which chemical causes which symptom in each person. It’s probably quite difficult to figure that out at times, but the findings have been replicated across four countries with consistent results, and they sit alongside objective clinical evidence. A 2024 systemic study in contact dermatitis found that among European dermatitis patients patch tested for allergy, 6.8 per cent were sensitised to a standard fragrance test mix. Fragrance remains one of the most common causes of allergic contact dermatitis worldwide. We do not have Tasmanian‑specific data, but there is no reason to think Tasmanians are less affected than any other Australians. If a natural figure holds here, we’re talking in the order of about 115,000 Tasmanians of working age being impacted.
This is not only a health issue. It is a workforce and access issue. Steinemann’s Australian national survey published in Preventive Medicine Reports in 2017 found that 7.7 per cent of Australians had lost workdays or a job in the previous year because of illness from fragrance products in the workplace. Across the four countries in the 2019 study, that figure was 9 per cent, with estimated personal costs exceeding US$146 billion in a single year. That’s a huge cost. The same Australian survey found that 16.4 per cent of people reported health problems from air fresheners and deodorisers, and that 16.7 per cent would enter a business and leave as quickly as possible because of fragrance products. At least you can have you have a choice there, whether you stay or leave. A workplace is not so straightforward.
The international study found that 13.3 per cent of people were unable to or reluctant to use a public restroom that has an air freshener – that includes staff and public toilets and I suggest it includes the staff and public toilets in this place that spray a scented thing all over the top of you when you go in there – and 22.7 per cent have been prevented from going somewhere because they would be exposed to a fragrant product that would make them unwell; that’s nearly 23 per cent.
Madam Acting President, we do need to think about what it means in practice – a person who cannot easily and comfortably use a bathroom at a public venue or in their workplace; a person who leaves a medical appointment because the waiting room is scented; a worker who takes sick leave rather than raise yet again a colleague’s perfume or the plug-in air freshener in the office kitchen. These people are what this motion is about. What we are looking at here is a straightforward productivity case. Lost workdays have a cost to employers, to the public sector and the economy.
Part of the difficulty is that people often don’t know what they’re being exposed to. A single fragrance is typically a mixture of dozens of compounds drawn from nearly 4000 documented fragrance ingredients. No law in any country requires full disclosure of the ingredients of the fragrance. In fact, they probably wouldn’t fit on the bottle, but a label can simply say ‘fragrance’ or ‘parfum’. For many household products it need not even say that.
In 2015, Steinemann tested 37 products – air-fresheners, laundry products, cleaners, and personal care products. Together, they emitted 156 different volatile organic compounds, an average of 15 per product; 42 of those were classified as ‘toxic’ or ‘hazardous.’ So, there were 155 detected; 42 were classified as toxic or hazardous under United States federal law. Fewer than 3 per cent of the compounds emitted were disclosed on any label or safety datasheet. The products marked as ‘green’ or ‘organic’ emitted hazardous compounds at a rate not significantly different from conventional products.
Most recent research has added a further dimension. Fragrance compounds such as such as limonene – a citrus scent that you might smell in a lot of cleaning products – reacts with ozone indoor to form secondary pollutants including formaldehyde and very fine products. There’s a real public health issue there. In 2025, researchers at Purdue University in the United States reported that air – fresheners, wax melts, floor cleaners and deodorants rapidly fill indoor air with nanoscale particles small enough to reach deep into the lungs. The same team reported that scented cleaning products, including those using plant-based essential oils, can briefly push indoor ultrafine particle levels above those outdoors. A study in London homes found that incense, oil diffusers and candles drove sharp increases in fine particle pollution during ordinary household use.
Again, to be clear, these studies measure exposure but do not yet establish long-term disease outcomes. But they tell us that the air in our offices, schools and hospitals is shaped by the products we choose to use in them and that is something institutions can control.
Fragrance sensitivity is invisible. There is a visible injury and that invisibility is the heart of the second part of this motion. People who raise it are too often met with scepticism or ridicule. They are told they’re being fussy or difficult or it’s all in their head. Some are made the subject of jokes. Many are ridiculed, belittled and mocked, as I was when I raised this matter earlier this year. Social media is a wonderful thing, isn’t it really? That didn’t have to happen. It should never have been an issue. So many stop raising it because of these responses and reactions. Some avoid events, decline invitations, take sick leave or leave jobs rather than ask again and be dismissed, ridiculed and/or belittled again.
Madam Acting President, there are times when I have not gone into a room where I know someone has perfume on that I just will not be able to breathe near. I don’t think it’s rude from my part, if you try and raise it. But I will say that the member for Hobart was wearing Chanel No.19 and it was giving me the most fearsome headache, and I mentioned it very gently and quietly to her. She was mortified that she had made me feel like that, and she has not worn it in this place since. So there, that is how we can deal with it, and I thank the member for Hobart for her compassion, care and respect.
Ms O’Connor – I never wear it around you.
Ms FORREST – You can wear whatever you like when I’m not there, that’s fine. This is the thing; it can be done when it’s done respectfully. Rather than being put down, diminished – there was no question of, ‘Oh, suck it up’, which I’ve heard from others. Not in this Chamber, I’m not suggesting, but certainly the member for Hobart’s response was entirely appropriate and I really appreciate it being so responsive.
The pattern is familiar, as with other invisible illnesses. It discourages disclosure. It discourages people from asking for reasonable adjustments, to which they may well be entitled under disability discrimination law, and it pushes people out of public and work life. I spoke to some people who contacted me from the mainland, who have actually been bullied out of their workplace when they raised it and then were told they couldn’t work at home, even though it was an office job, and so they had no choice but to leave work.
We have been here before, not so long ago it was considered unreasonable to ask someone not to smoke in a shared office or restaurant. I remember being very pregnant with my first child at an event. We were sitting at these tables during a collective dinner, and after main course, before dessert, the man across the table leant back and said, ‘You don’t mind if I smoke, do you?’ and I said, ‘Yes, I do.’ He looked at me and said, ‘What am I going to do then?’, and I said ‘Well, how about you don’t smoke?’ He said, ‘No, I can smoke.’ He was just mortified. He did have the decency to ask; he just didn’t want to hear the answer. But he did smoke, and so I went outside. I chose not to smoke during my pregnancies. I chose to try to protect my babies as much as I possibly could, while I could, while they were in utero. He had no right to expose me to that. I had to make the change, not him. What a surprise.
Today smoke-free indoor environments simply are expected. I’m not suggesting fragrance is equivalent to tobacco smoke in its health impacts or effects, but I am suggesting that how we treat people affected by an airborne trigger reflects a cultural choice and cultures can change. Institutions have a role in modelling that change. When someone raises a health or accessibility concern, the response should be respectful and informed by evidence, and that concern should be handled with confidentiality, dignity and professionalism. This was far from my own personal experience. Confidentiality, dignity and professionalism should be the baseline in any workplace, and especially in public institutions, including this one.
The good news is that the response is practical and inexpensive. It won’t cost the government anything. There is a clear public appetite across the four countries in Steinemann’s study, 47.8 per cent of people would support a fragrance-free policy in their workplace, compared with 20.4 per cent who would not. So, most people, even if it doesn’t affect them, would still be happy to support it. More than twice as many people would prefer healthcare facilities, hotels and aeroplanes to be fragrance-free rather than fragranced.
There were times when you used to get on an aeroplane and the front section was a smoking section and the back was a non-smoking section. So, if you didn’t want to smoke you sat at the back, and if you wanted to smoke you sat at the front because the smoke only stayed in the front section, not. At the time it was just the way it was and you couldn’t possibly complain. It didn’t do you any good if you did.
Mr President, the measures that I think that can easily be undertaken, and they’re hardly earth-shattering, are:
- choosing fragrance‑free cleaning and hygiene products in government buildings, schools and health facilities, which are widely available and often no more expensive;
- removing automatic air fresheners and plug‑in diffusers from shared spaces;
- including fragrance awareness in workplace health and safety and inclusion policies;
- encourage people to go lightly in shared places rather than prohibiting anything ‑
I’m not suggesting we say people can’t wear any sort of fragrance; it’s those really strong, overbearing fragrances and aftershaves and things like that that you can smell a mile off. In fact, when you walk past someone in the street, if you’re walking behind them, you’ll smell it far before you catch up with them;
- noting fragrance‑reduced arrangements in event information as we do for wheelchair access or dietary needs –
I mean, it’s one of the things that we could easily include;
- having a clear, confidential process for people to raise concerns where they feel safe and respected;
- respecting an individual’s personal health‑related information by maintaining confidentiality beyond those who need to know –
That’d be a nice start. One caution from recent research is worth heeding. A 2026 study of fragrance-free policies found they often focus narrowly on perfume while overlooking cleaning and laundry products, air fresheners and building materials. Any guidance should look at all sources, starting with those an institution directly controls. Some things are beyond our control, but there are plenty of things that are.
I do also note when I asked some of our staff some years ago when they were bringing fresh flowers in, and some incense sticks ‑ which is very nice, but they’re pretty overpowering at times; lilies would just about kill you, jonquils, from my perspective, are so overpowering ‑ when I gently made that request they were removed and now we’ve got Lego flowers, which are just as beautiful, including in our Deputy Usher’s office ‑
Mr PRESIDENT – A full garden.
Ms FORREST – many nice flowers and others. A lot of our secretarial staff have got lovely Lego flowers in their offices, so there’s all different ways of addressing this.
This is why the motion calls on the government are measured. It asks the government to consider what steps can be taken with its own services and public institutions. It asks the government to consider whether public health guidance could be developed or promoted for employers, event organisers, schools and healthcare facilities. It asks the government to reflect on the importance of confidentiality and trust when people raise health and accessibility concerns – a matter they have failed on at least one occasion I’m personally aware of. None of this actually requires legislation. None of it requires significant expenditure. It requires leadership, compassion and a willingness to listen and act.
One in three Australians report that everyday fragrance products make them unwell. For around one in 10, the effects are disabling. Many of them are in our workplaces, our schools, our hospitals and our public spaces. Most are dealing with it quietly. The evidence has limits as much of it is self-reported, but the weight of it from population surveys, clinical allergy data and indoor air research points in one direction: fragrance sensitivity is real, it is common and it can be serious. The motion asks us to acknowledge that reality. It asks us to acknowledge the people affected, to support a culture where they are believed rather than dismissed, ridiculed or belittled, and to encourage the government to take reasonable, practical steps within its own institutions.
I commend the motion and look forward to the contribution of other members.
